NHS v Servier: unlawful means tort claim fails, but the long-running saga continues

17-08-2021

Beatriz San Martin and Shishu Chen

NHS v Servier: unlawful means tort claim fails, but the long-running saga continues

marbury / Shutterstock.com

The latest episode in the long-running dispute between the NHS and French pharmaceutical company Servier has been marked by a UK Supreme Court judgment of July 2, 2021 on Servier’s application to strike out the NHS’s unlawful means tort claim.

In this article, we summarise the Supreme Court’s judgment which upholds the lower courts’ decisions in refusing to allow the NHS to avail itself of the tort of unlawful means against Servier, and we comment on the reasoning of the Supreme Court.

Background

Servier, a pharmaceutical company headquartered in France, develops and manufactures perindopril, which is used in the treatment of cardiovascular diseases. In 2001, Servier applied to the European Patent Office (EPO) for a patent for the alpha crystalline form of perindopril (European Patent UK 1,296,947). The patent was granted by the EPO in 2004 and upheld by the Opposition Division of the European Patent Office (EPO) in 2006.


NHS, Servier, tort claim, UK Supreme Court, EPO, generics, patent application, plaintiff, fraud, IP

LSIPR