Ferring calls for sanctions on Jones Day


Alex Baldwin

Ferring calls for sanctions on Jones Day

Oleschwander / Shutterstock.com

Ferring Pharmaceuticals has asked The District Court for the Southern District of New York to impose sanctions on law firm Jones Day for allegedly forcing its client Serenity Pharmaceuticals into pursuing litigation against Ferring.

The Swiss pharmaceutical company requests that the law firm, and specifically lead attorney  Chris Harnett, pay at least $1 million dollars to Ferring to cover attorney’s fees, expenses and costs related to Serenity’s appearance in court in July 2019 in a trial related to Ferring et al v Allergan et al.

Serenity filed counterclaims against Jones Day after the firm sued Serenity and its principals in New York state court. In the counterclaims Serenity alleges that it asked Jones Day to withdraw counterclaims before the July 2019 trial.

Ferring accuses Chris Harnet, the lead Jones Day attorney for the trial, of threatening Serenity with accusations that Ferring would pursue legal action against Serenity executives if claims were withdrawn.

According to Ferring, Jones Day had not informed the court, nor Ferring, that Serenity had wanted to withdraw their counterclaims.

“If they had withdrawn, the trial in this case could have been avoided in its entirety,” the filing says.

Ferring has made clear that it would not oppose Jones Day’s withdrawal as counsel if the counterclaims are dismissed with prejudice.

“Because of the actions of Jones Day, including specifically those of Chris Harnett, the parties were forced to try claims that Jones Day’s own client did not want to pursue.

“Therefore, Ferring respectfully requests that this Court use its inherent power and/or the authority provided by 28 U.S.C. § 1927 to sanction Jones Day and Chris Harnett for the excess costs, expenses, and attorneys’ fees that Ferring unnecessarily incurred in relation to the July 2019 trial,” the document said.

The Ferring v Allergan lawsuit first began in 2012 when Ferring filed a complaint in April 2012 concerning the ownership of certain desmopressin patents. Dr Seymour Fein had developed the drug from 1998 to 2002 as a consultant for Ferring.

With his work not under any obligation to assign inventions, both Fein and Ferring filed duelling patent applications covering different aspects of the drug. Both parents were approved and Fein assigned patents to Allergan.

WIPR has approached Jones Day for comment.

Did you enjoy reading this story? Sign up to our free daily newsletters and get stories sent like this straight to your inbox

Ferring Pharmaceuticals, Serenity, Jones Day, Allergan